TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
- Pieter du Toit
- Patrolman
- Posts: 762
- Joined: 06 May 2009 15:04
- Full Name: Pieter Joubert du Toit
- Nickname: PJ of ook Whitey
- Home Town: Welgemoed
- Current 4x4: 2002 Nissan Patrol GRX TD42T CONVERSION
- Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Cape Town
- Been thanked: 4 times
TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Hi all,
Firstly, before I even post my question, let me say that answers / opinions from any forum member are welcome - the only reason my topic says "TD42 Owners" because as owners of these vehicles they will be able to answer from experience.
We all have seen and read the various posts about the "over heating" problem of our vehicles - especially when woring hard and ambient temperatures are high. My question is as follows:
Has any TD42 (turbo or N/A) owner added an oil cooler to your vehicles - and if you did so what was the results re your running temperatures??? And what size oil cooler did you use??
As most of you know me and Frans is about to add this to my Patrol - and I am going to do it come hell or high water - but are curious to know whether anybody else has done it. From my research it does not seem that there is a spesific "recipe" in determining what size the oil cooler must be - and that's my biggest concern. Too small might end up not having any effect (which intend to make you think it is not working) and to big could also cool the oil down too much - which has a negative impact on wear and tear (but at least you wil know you are going the right direction).
Well I have bought all the materials needed and we are going to start with a 25 row oil cooler (300 x 200 x 50) - and I will also be adding the oil temerature and oil pressure monitoring functions incorported in the Madman EMS.
Your opinions please.
Regards
Firstly, before I even post my question, let me say that answers / opinions from any forum member are welcome - the only reason my topic says "TD42 Owners" because as owners of these vehicles they will be able to answer from experience.
We all have seen and read the various posts about the "over heating" problem of our vehicles - especially when woring hard and ambient temperatures are high. My question is as follows:
Has any TD42 (turbo or N/A) owner added an oil cooler to your vehicles - and if you did so what was the results re your running temperatures??? And what size oil cooler did you use??
As most of you know me and Frans is about to add this to my Patrol - and I am going to do it come hell or high water - but are curious to know whether anybody else has done it. From my research it does not seem that there is a spesific "recipe" in determining what size the oil cooler must be - and that's my biggest concern. Too small might end up not having any effect (which intend to make you think it is not working) and to big could also cool the oil down too much - which has a negative impact on wear and tear (but at least you wil know you are going the right direction).
Well I have bought all the materials needed and we are going to start with a 25 row oil cooler (300 x 200 x 50) - and I will also be adding the oil temerature and oil pressure monitoring functions incorported in the Madman EMS.
Your opinions please.
Regards
Pieter du Toit
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 106
- Joined: 23 Aug 2010 10:59
- Full Name: Adrian
- Nickname: Adrian
- Home Town: Johannesburg
- Current 4x4: '91 SWB Patrol 4.2d
- Home Language: English
- Been thanked: 1 time
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Hi Pieter, I don't have a turbo on my vehicle, but I'll post my thoughts on the matter in anycase. I don't believe a an oil cooler will provide any significant reduction of the engine temperature as the heat transfer between the oil and water will not be that great. I have read about 3-core radiators making very little difference which suggests the insufficient water is passing through the engine. I believe the only viable solution to the overheating problem would be to increase the flow. This could be achieved relatively easily by changing the pulley on the water pump. Reducing the diameter of the pump pulley by 20% will give you a 44% increase in pump delivery head. The resultant increase in flow through the engine will however depend on how restrictive the the water channels in the engine are. This should be relatively cheap and would be your best option to get your troll cool under the collar. Cheers and good luck.
- Peter Connan
- Moderator
- Posts: 6011
- Joined: 10 Sep 2010 07:21
- Full Name: Peter Connan
- Nickname: Piet
- Home Town: Kempton Park
- Current 4x4: 1996 Patrol 4.5SGL
- Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Kempton Park
- Has thanked: 1067 times
- Been thanked: 985 times
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Hello Pieter
Once more I am opening my big yap without relevant experience.
Firstly, I beleive that reducing oil temperature has little effect in reducing engine temperature, however it is still a good thing to do because in the type of situations we are talking about the oil temperature also tends to rise to unacceptable levels.
The only experience I have with oil coolers is from relatively small-engined racing cars, and typically a 1600-2000cc racing car would use an oil cooler slightly smaller than half the size you are talking about. The oil cooler in my Birkin 7 fitted with a tuned and dry-sumped Ford Kent 1600 engine was about 250mm x 120mm x 50mm, so I suspect you are not too far from right?
Good luck, and please let us know what the results are.
Peter
Once more I am opening my big yap without relevant experience.
Firstly, I beleive that reducing oil temperature has little effect in reducing engine temperature, however it is still a good thing to do because in the type of situations we are talking about the oil temperature also tends to rise to unacceptable levels.
The only experience I have with oil coolers is from relatively small-engined racing cars, and typically a 1600-2000cc racing car would use an oil cooler slightly smaller than half the size you are talking about. The oil cooler in my Birkin 7 fitted with a tuned and dry-sumped Ford Kent 1600 engine was about 250mm x 120mm x 50mm, so I suspect you are not too far from right?
Good luck, and please let us know what the results are.
Peter
Mag ons ons kenniskry met lekkerkry aanhoukry.
- Herrie
- Patrolman 1000+
- Posts: 2999
- Joined: 08 Apr 2009 07:17
- Full Name: Kobus Pienaar
- Nickname: Herrie
- Home Town: Kempton Park
- Current 4x4: 1999 Patrol 4500e GRX
1983 Datsun Safari - Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Kempton Park
- Has thanked: 55 times
- Been thanked: 93 times
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Will an oilcooler work when you drive slow off-road?? No wind pressure to be forced through to cooler!
Herrie op Safari/Patrollie
1983 Safari
1999 Patrol 4500 GRX
1983 Safari
1999 Patrol 4500 GRX
- ChristoSlang
- Patrolman
- Posts: 851
- Joined: 07 Apr 2009 16:54
- Full Name: Christo van Rensburg
- Nickname: ChristoSlang
- Home Town: Pretoria, ZA
- Current 4x4: Nissan 4.2 GL Patrol
- Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Garsfontein, Pretoria
- Has thanked: 17 times
- Been thanked: 116 times
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Gents, I noticed at our dyno day this morning that Cedric's "Iron Maiden" has an oil cooler. Maybe he'll tell us more?
Increase surface area and you lose heat, add airflow and you lose heat faster. An oil cooler with its related plumbing already does the former, so I'm sure it will help even when you're standing still
What I'm not sure of is how hot a Patrol's oil gets (my EMS magafter is missing that sensor!) and by how much an oil cooler will cool it down. Our td42 motors have nearly 10 liters of oil circulating through them - roughly the same volume as the engine coolant? Losing some heat there is bound to help? I realise the oil circuits were never designed to run past hot areas like the coolant circuits are, but it may just help?
I'll be watching this thread with interest...
Increase surface area and you lose heat, add airflow and you lose heat faster. An oil cooler with its related plumbing already does the former, so I'm sure it will help even when you're standing still
What I'm not sure of is how hot a Patrol's oil gets (my EMS magafter is missing that sensor!) and by how much an oil cooler will cool it down. Our td42 motors have nearly 10 liters of oil circulating through them - roughly the same volume as the engine coolant? Losing some heat there is bound to help? I realise the oil circuits were never designed to run past hot areas like the coolant circuits are, but it may just help?
I'll be watching this thread with interest...
- Pieter du Toit
- Patrolman
- Posts: 762
- Joined: 06 May 2009 15:04
- Full Name: Pieter Joubert du Toit
- Nickname: PJ of ook Whitey
- Home Town: Welgemoed
- Current 4x4: 2002 Nissan Patrol GRX TD42T CONVERSION
- Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Cape Town
- Been thanked: 4 times
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Herrie,Herrie wrote:Will an oilcooler work when you drive slow off-road?? No wind pressure to be forced through to cooler!
To answer your question / statement - we (well I do) only experience the overheating problem when driving fast (80km/h) up a steep slope / hill / incline for long distances with a heavy loaded car or trailor in tow. Not once has my car overheated or the temperature gauge moved under 4x4 circumstances (40km/h and less) - not even with the trailor in tow or the Patrol loaded. I m sure that some of the mods we have already done already goes a long way in contributing to this part of the overheating aspect.
Regards
PS: I am sure to keep everyone informed - and thanks for you guys' opinions thus far as well. Cedric where are you - what's you experience with the oil cooler fiited to the Iron Maiden??
Pieter du Toit
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
- Ross
- Senior Member
- Posts: 285
- Joined: 19 May 2009 13:41
- Full Name: Ross Holland
- Nickname: Ross
- Home Town: Cape Town
- Current 4x4: 1998 GU 4.2 Turbo Diesel
aka "The Polar Bear" - Home Language: English
- Has thanked: 4 times
- Been thanked: 11 times
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Hav`nt had the overheating issue yet, but my turbo setup is pretty conservative and I havn`t towed long distance with the Trol yet.
Never the less....I am watching this thread with interest!
Never the less....I am watching this thread with interest!
Ross
1998 GU 4.2 Turbo Diesel: 2" OME, 33" Big Horns, 2x LR Tanks, Safari Snorkel, Dual Battery, Drawer System, etc etc
aka "The Polar Bear"
1998 GU 4.2 Turbo Diesel: 2" OME, 33" Big Horns, 2x LR Tanks, Safari Snorkel, Dual Battery, Drawer System, etc etc
aka "The Polar Bear"
- Pieter du Toit
- Patrolman
- Posts: 762
- Joined: 06 May 2009 15:04
- Full Name: Pieter Joubert du Toit
- Nickname: PJ of ook Whitey
- Home Town: Welgemoed
- Current 4x4: 2002 Nissan Patrol GRX TD42T CONVERSION
- Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Cape Town
- Been thanked: 4 times
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Hi Gents
Just a bit of an update - the oil cooler is fitted and together with that the oil temperature sensor and oil pressure sensor. Thanks again to Frans who's really assisting me in trying to get the heat problem sorted.
The pipeworks between the sandwich plate and the cooler itself was completed by Omar piping in Stikland yesterday.
So after a good run in yesterday's 32 degrees in Cape Town I can at least say the oil leak poblem was sorted out...... What I did notice is oil pressure seemed to be around 4 - 6 bar (differs everytime I accellerate) and oil temperature seemed to be between 82 - 88 degrees. Did not go higher than 90 gegrees once but it was all town and short but sprinting type driving - "pedal to the metal" driving through all the gears"
Its not been tested at all yet (except for a "leak test" during driving). Currently Mufasa is standing at Burnco for the relocation of my winch electrical box (was on the bumper between the spot lights), cutting a bigger whole in the bumper for extra airflow onto the coolerand the fitment of a plate underneath the bumper to direct airflow.
Come Friday will hook the trailer and take it in tow with me to Pearly Beach for the weekend - just to tow it over Sir Lowry's Pass and see how it behaves
Early next week I will be able to tell you all where I stand.............until then I you.!!!
Just a bit of an update - the oil cooler is fitted and together with that the oil temperature sensor and oil pressure sensor. Thanks again to Frans who's really assisting me in trying to get the heat problem sorted.
The pipeworks between the sandwich plate and the cooler itself was completed by Omar piping in Stikland yesterday.
So after a good run in yesterday's 32 degrees in Cape Town I can at least say the oil leak poblem was sorted out...... What I did notice is oil pressure seemed to be around 4 - 6 bar (differs everytime I accellerate) and oil temperature seemed to be between 82 - 88 degrees. Did not go higher than 90 gegrees once but it was all town and short but sprinting type driving - "pedal to the metal" driving through all the gears"
Its not been tested at all yet (except for a "leak test" during driving). Currently Mufasa is standing at Burnco for the relocation of my winch electrical box (was on the bumper between the spot lights), cutting a bigger whole in the bumper for extra airflow onto the coolerand the fitment of a plate underneath the bumper to direct airflow.
Come Friday will hook the trailer and take it in tow with me to Pearly Beach for the weekend - just to tow it over Sir Lowry's Pass and see how it behaves
Early next week I will be able to tell you all where I stand.............until then I you.!!!
Pieter du Toit
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
-
- Patrolman
- Posts: 789
- Joined: 18 Aug 2009 14:52
- Full Name: JG Shields
- Nickname: JG
- Home Town: Pretoria
- Current 4x4: Toyota Land Cruiser 105 GX 4500 EFi
- Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Pretoria
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
Pieter,
Ek is bly jy is so ver. Wat was die verkoeler se skoonmaak resultate?
Alhoewel en my nie by hierdie debat behoort te bepaal nie, was dit vir my al opvallend om BAAAAIE mense se opinier te hoor rakende die 4.2D se sogenaamde "warm word" probleem. Daar word beweer dat dit 'n algemene probleem is, dat die AUssies nie baie bekommerd daaroor is nie aangesien die EGT's reg kan bly ongeag die lesing van die watertemp op die bestuurders naald. Die vraag word ook gevra op die betrokke enjins se waterkanale in die blok nie dalk te klein/nou is nie. Nietemin, dit klink of ons die enigstes is wat bekommerd is hieroor en dat die 4.2D enjins in ander lande hoe kilos doen met die sogenaamde probleem en al.
Ek is bly jy is so ver. Wat was die verkoeler se skoonmaak resultate?
Alhoewel en my nie by hierdie debat behoort te bepaal nie, was dit vir my al opvallend om BAAAAIE mense se opinier te hoor rakende die 4.2D se sogenaamde "warm word" probleem. Daar word beweer dat dit 'n algemene probleem is, dat die AUssies nie baie bekommerd daaroor is nie aangesien die EGT's reg kan bly ongeag die lesing van die watertemp op die bestuurders naald. Die vraag word ook gevra op die betrokke enjins se waterkanale in die blok nie dalk te klein/nou is nie. Nietemin, dit klink of ons die enigstes is wat bekommerd is hieroor en dat die 4.2D enjins in ander lande hoe kilos doen met die sogenaamde probleem en al.
Patrol fan!
- Pieter du Toit
- Patrolman
- Posts: 762
- Joined: 06 May 2009 15:04
- Full Name: Pieter Joubert du Toit
- Nickname: PJ of ook Whitey
- Home Town: Welgemoed
- Current 4x4: 2002 Nissan Patrol GRX TD42T CONVERSION
- Home Language: Afrikaans
- Location: Cape Town
- Been thanked: 4 times
Re: TD42 OWNERS QUESTION
JG,
Ek dink dis die lekker ding van die forum - alhoewel n sekere "topic" jou as individu nie nootwendig direk raak nie is dit lekker en goed om ander se opinies en opvattings ens te hoor. So jy is welkom om betrokke te wees / raak.
Ek het nog nie by die radiator se skoonmaak / flush uit gekom nie. Om die chemiese skoonmaak proses te volg moet die radiator uitkom daar voor en met die die 4.2 is dit nie n grap nie. Ek gaan nou maar eers die naweek kyk na die resultate met net die oil cooler op voor ek nog enige verdere besluite neem. Die aanmekaar se oneindige geld spandeer aan die Patrol raak nou ook n seer "subject" met Swambo - die oil cooler conversion kos my nou ook alweer net onder die R5000-00 saam met al die pype, fittings, oil temp en pressure sensors en ekstra VDO meter vir die olie druk. So ja iewers moet dit stop - ek wil oor n maand met vakansie ook gaan!!
Sal laat weet wat is my "verdict" met die oil cooler. Net jammer Mufasa staan by Burnco - dis die afgelope paar dae lekker vrek warm hieronder in die Kaap en moes ek hom nou selfs net vir normale gebruik kon toets. Hoop maar die weer hou so vir die naweek ook.
Groete
Ek dink dis die lekker ding van die forum - alhoewel n sekere "topic" jou as individu nie nootwendig direk raak nie is dit lekker en goed om ander se opinies en opvattings ens te hoor. So jy is welkom om betrokke te wees / raak.
Ek het nog nie by die radiator se skoonmaak / flush uit gekom nie. Om die chemiese skoonmaak proses te volg moet die radiator uitkom daar voor en met die die 4.2 is dit nie n grap nie. Ek gaan nou maar eers die naweek kyk na die resultate met net die oil cooler op voor ek nog enige verdere besluite neem. Die aanmekaar se oneindige geld spandeer aan die Patrol raak nou ook n seer "subject" met Swambo - die oil cooler conversion kos my nou ook alweer net onder die R5000-00 saam met al die pype, fittings, oil temp en pressure sensors en ekstra VDO meter vir die olie druk. So ja iewers moet dit stop - ek wil oor n maand met vakansie ook gaan!!
Sal laat weet wat is my "verdict" met die oil cooler. Net jammer Mufasa staan by Burnco - dis die afgelope paar dae lekker vrek warm hieronder in die Kaap en moes ek hom nou selfs net vir normale gebruik kon toets. Hoop maar die weer hou so vir die naweek ook.
Groete
Pieter du Toit
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
MUFASA
2002 - 2010 Patrol 3.0L TDi GRX - HANDGRANADE WENT BOOM!!
2010 TD42T GRX CONVERSION - SADLY SOLD!!
2005 4.8GRX - Ama-GluG GluG - SADLY SOLD!!
Cell no: 072 606 7007
Fax no: 086 500 9333
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests